Close
Date TimeFebruary 21, 2018
VoiceQuestions over immigration status of Viktor and Amalija Knavs have escalated since the president proposed ending the ability of U.S. citizens to sponsor their parents and siblings for legal residency. Experts say that path would have been the most likely method for his in-laws to obtain their green cards.
Melania Trump’s parents are legal permanent residents. Experts say that means they likely relied on ‘chain migration,’ which Donald Trump has condemned
WASHINGTON—The parents of first lady Melania Trump have become legal permanent residents of the United States and are close to obtaining their citizenship, according to people familiar with their status, but their attorney declined to say how or when the couple gained their green cards.
Immigration experts said Viktor and Amalija Knavs very likely relied on a family reunification process that President Trump has derided as “chain migration” and proposed ending in such cases.
The Knavses, formerly of Slovenia, are living in the country on green cards, according to Michael Wildes, a New York-based immigration attorney who represents the first lady and her family.
“I can confirm that Mrs. Trump’s parents are both lawfully admitted to the United States as permanent residents,” he said. “The family, as they are not part of the administration, has asked that their privacy be respected so I will not comment further on this matter.”
The Knavses are now awaiting scheduling for their swearing-in ceremony, according to a person with knowledge of the parents’ immigration filings.
Questions over the Knavses’ immigration status have escalated since Trump campaigned for the White House on a hard-line anti-immigration agenda. Those questions grew sharper last month, when the president proposed ending the decades-long ability of U.S. citizens to sponsor their parents and siblings for legal residency in the United States.
Trump has repeatedly blasted the long-standing policy as “chain migration.” In last month’s State of the Union, the president called that process a threat to Americans’ security and quality of life. Under his plan, he said, only spouses and minor children could be sponsored for legal residency.
But immigration experts said such a path would have been the most likely method his in-laws would have used to obtain residency that permits them to live in the United States.
Matthew Kolken, a partner at a New York immigration law firm, said there are only two substantive ways Trump’s in-laws could gain green cards: by their daughter sponsoring them or by an employer sponsoring them. The latter is unlikely, as it would require a showing that there were no Americans who could do the job for which they were sought.
Both the Knavses are reportedly retired. In Slovenia, Viktor Knavs, now 73, worked as a chauffeur and car salesman. Amalija Knavs, now 71, was a pattern maker at a textile factory.
David Leopold, an immigration lawyer and a past president of the American Immigration Lawyers Association, said the first lady’s sponsorship of her parents appears to be the only reasonable way they would have obtained green cards because the process currently gives preferential treatments to parents of a U.S. citizen.
“That would be the logical way to do it, the preferred way to do it and possibly the only way to do it under the facts that I know,” Leopold said.
Foreigners can also petition for refugee status or other humanitarian programs, according to the Department of Homeland Security.
A White House spokesman and a spokeswoman for the first lady declined to comment.
Melania Trump came to the United States from Slovenia in 1996 for several modelling assignments, first on a visitor’s visa and then a work permit. In 2000, Trump self-sponsored herself for a green card based on her “extraordinary ability” as a model, according to information Wildes previously released.
In 2001, several years after meeting Donald Trump, she received a green card that granted her permanent residency. She became a U.S. citizen in 2006, the year after she and Trump were married.
The Knavses have lived on and off with the Trumps in New York City for years and have been seen frequently in Washington since the first lady moved into the White House last summer.
Several years ago, their attorneys contacted the office of Sen. Charles E. Schumer (D-N.Y.), now the Democratic minority leader, for help checking on the status of their petition for a green card with U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, according to a person familiar with the outreach.
Such efforts are not unusual and some congressional staffs, including Schumer’s, have a dedicated immigration case worker to handle such requests. Schumer’s office declined to comment.
In his State of the Union address on Jan. 30, Trump offered a four-point immigration reform plan that he said “protects the nuclear family by ending chain migration.”
“Under the current broken system, a single immigrant can bring in virtually unlimited numbers of distant relatives,” the president said in his speech. “Under our plan, we focus on the immediate family by limiting sponsorships to spouses and minor children. This vital reform is necessary, not just for our economy, but for our security, and our future.”
Trump underscored his position in a Feb. 6 tweet.
“We need a 21st Century MERIT-BASED immigration system,” he tweeted. “Chain migration and the visa lottery are outdated programs that hurt our economic and national security.”
Democrats and some Republicans have vociferously opposed that measure. Last week, the Senate defeated legislation offered by Republican Sen. Charles E. Grassley and backed by the White House that included Trump’s proposal.

Jimmy Kimmel Explains His Reaction to Fergie's "Unusually Sultry" National Anthem at NBA All-Star Game
Bill Gates flunks Ellen's grocery shopping challenge
Actress Karla Souza alleges she was raped by director
Spokesman: Evangelist Billy Graham has died at age 99
Sky U.K. Orders Weekly ‘Late Late Show With James Corden’ Highlights Program
Uber Express is like a minibus with cheaper rides
Growth of AI could expand security threats if no action taken, report warns
Queen makes surprise appearance at London fashion week
Late-Night Hosts Applaud Florida Students Demanding Action on Gun Control
Jared Kushner reportedly doesn’t want to give up his security clearance
US Vice President Mike Pence was set to meet with North Korean officials, but they canceled
There are no longer any words to describe Syria's horror
Olympic ice skating: Medvedeva sets world record, then Zagitova breaks it
Congress wonders if this time will be different for gun control
George and Amal Clooney to attend March For Our Lives
Donald Trump Jr. promotes Trump brand, new luxury developments in India
How the #MeToo women’s movement is changing politics
Turkey 'opens fire on Syrian regime forces' coming to the aid of Kurds in Afrin
Alleged $150K payoff to Trump accuser, ex-Playboy model Karen McDougal: Was it illegal?
Kim Jong Un's sister, Kim Yo Jong, is pregnant, report says
China and Europe love SpaceX's new Falcon Heavy rocket. Does NASA?
Say goodbye to Android Pay and hello to Google Pay
‘Black Panther’ Marks A New Kind Of Black Superhero Movie
Chelsea prepare for Barcelona clash but what is David Luiz doing to Tiemoue Bakayoko?
Man City star Sergio Aguero 'PUNCHES' Wigan fan after shocking FA Cup defeat - WATCH
American ice dance duo Madison Chock and Evan Bates suffer shocking fall in long program
Meghan Markle receives royal secretary ahead of wedding to Prince Harry
President Trump endorses Mitt Romney in Utah Senate race
Oxfam apologises to Haiti over sex allegations
Jimmy Fallon Duets With Paul Rudd in Olympics-Shortened, 5-Minute Version of 'Tonight Show'
Woman from iconic shooting photo: I hate it
Winter Olympics: Golden comeback for Canadian skaters Moir and Virtue
Al Franken was accused of sexual harassment. Now, he’s canceled his Miami appearance
Google hopes AI can predict heart disease by looking at retinas
Pennsylvania Supreme Court issues new election map
Tessa Virtue And Scott Moir Break Their Own World Record In Ice Dance Short Program
Afrin: Syria 'sending fighters to help Kurds against Turkey'
Kremlin dismisses Mueller's indictment of 13 Russians
Duchess of Cambridge opts for green as black dresses sweep BAFTAs
Draymond Green laughed at Fergie's bizarre anthem performance
May warns universities over high cost of tuition fees
BREAKING: Mexico hit by 6.1 magnitude earthquake - people in streets as quake rocks Oaxaca
Six-year-old CHILD and three others wounded in Texas shooting, gunman at large
Trump slams Oprah, hopes to see her 2020 run to 'expose and defeat'
Berlin: 'Game of Thrones' Producer Frank Doelger to Head Intaglio Films (Exclusive)
Two hikers missing after Swiss avalanche
SpaceX to launch demo satellites for its high-speed internet project
5 killed in church shooting in Dagestan
Emma Watson donates £1 million to anti-sexual harassment campaign
The Latest: Netanyahu to Poland: Don't rewrite Holocaust
Greg Gutfeld's review of the Winter Olympics
SpaceX Delays Next Falcon 9 Rocket Launch to Feb. 21
Passenger plane crashes in Iran with 66 aboard, report says
Reports: Padres, 1B Eric Hosmer agree to deal
Neil Kinnock warns Jeremy Corbyn: ‘Stop Brexit to save the NHS’
Florida Agency Investigated Nikolas Cruz After Violent Social Media Posts
Trump Cites Facebook Executive In ‘Fake News’ Twitter Rant Over Indictments
13 dead after helicopter crash at Mexico earthquake site
Nathan Chen makes Olympic history by landing 6 quads
Wales shaken by 4.4 magnitude earthquake
Nigeria: three suicide bombers kill at least 20 people at market
BREAKING: Great Portland Street fire: 50 fire fighters swarm Soho near BBC building
Russia's Lavrov says reports on US election interference 'just blather'
Italian police clashes with anti-fascists leaves 7 injured
Trump meets Florida school shooting survivors as calls grow for tougher gun laws
Alleged Ex-Trump Paramour Says 'Catch And Kill' Practice Kept Her Quiet
Big Mexico quake cuts power and damages homes; two dead in crash
Trump visits Florida hospital, sheriff's office after Parkland shooting
'Did you learn anything new today?' Angela Merkel SMIRKS after this Brexit question
FBI failed to act on tip accused Florida gunman wanted to kill
Mueller indicts 13 Russian nationals over 2016 US election meddling
Mitt Romney, Trump critic on the right, poised for Senate run in Utah
Theresa May heads to Berlin to try and bypass Michel Barnier, but will it work? 
London Fashion Week protested by topless PETA activists and plus size women in lingerie
Canary Islands La Palma volcano hit by 70 earthquakes sparking emergency response
Skater Nathan Chen bobbles his Olympic short program; Yuzuru Hanyu leads
Black Panther's Chadwick Boseman: 'Everybody’s minds are opening up'
Google Image Search removes View Image button and Search by Image feature
Jennifer Aniston and Justin Theroux announce separation
Jimmy Kimmel Parody Ad Mocks Trump Lawyer Porn Star Payoff
Read Trump's speech addressing the Parkland school shooting
Florida shooting: First look as Nikolas Cruz arrives at jail, handcuffed in hospital robe
UK blames Russia for 'malicious' NotPetya cyber-attack
US superstar Mikaela Shiffrin wins giant slalom gold
'Incredibles 2' Olympics Spot Is a Super-Powered Family Reunion
Jacob Zuma resigns as South Africa's president on eve of no-confidence vote
Allison Janney on How Tonya Harding Reacted to 'I, Tonya'
CNN Analyst Tears Up During Live Broadcast of Florida Shooting Coverage
Who is Florida school shooting suspect Nikolas Cruz?
US Vice President Mike Pence says he ignored Kim Jong Un's sister
Cisco: We're moving our $67 billion cash pile to the U.S
Real Madrid v PSG: Champions League
Florida school shooting suspect in custody, police say
Former Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney to run for Senate: source
Barack and Michelle Obama post sweet tweets to each other for Valentine's Day
Trump Threatens to Veto Immigration Bills that Don't Meet His Demands
How 'I, Tonya' Editor Made the Nancy Kerrigan Assault Scary Again
The FBI, CIA and NSA say American citizens shouldn't use Huawei phones
Celebrate Valentine's Day tonight - and fast on Ash Wednesday tomorrow, Catholics told 
Heathrow Airport crash: One dead and plane evacuated after horrifying collision on tarmac
Google's Chrome ad blocking arrives tomorrow and this is how it works
Authorities respond to shooting at NSA facility
The Latest: Israel opposition calls on Netanyahu to resign
Engine Cover Blows Off on United Airlines Flight
How a porn star taught a law class on Kimmel's show
Shaun White Makes History With Gold Medal Win In Halfpipe
Full time in Turin: Juventus 2-2 Tottenham Hotspur
White House wants to deliver food to the poor, Blue Apron-style
US-led strikes kill 100 RUSSIANS in first armed conflict between nations since Vietnam War
Israeli police to recommend indicting Netanyahu over alleged bribery in two cases: media
Have years of scandal finally caught up with Jacob Zuma?
Russian plane crash caused by pilots’ error on speed data, investigators say
Oxfam workers could face UK prosecution over sex crimes 
Julian Assange, founder of WikiLeaks, loses court bid to have UK arrest warrant dropped
Bill & Melinda Gates: Why we give our money away
'The Bachelor' recap: Three women exit before the hometown dates
Julian Assange saga: judge to rule on arrest warrant
Watch Boston Dynamics' Creepy Robot Dogs Team Up To Enter Your Nightmares
Chloe Kim wins gold in women's snowboard halfpipe at 2018 Winter Olympics
YouTube not ready to kick out Logan Paul, CEO Susan Wojcicki says
Questions surround death of environmentalist in Iranian prison
'Chelsea Bomber' Ahmad Rahimi to be sentenced Tuesday
Kim Jong Un 'impressed' with South Korea's efforts, state media says
Report: Japanese speedskater Kei Saito has positive doping test
Trump Jr.'s wife rushed to hospital after opening letter with white powder
Unilever warns social media to clean up “toxic” content
White House budget proposes increase to defense spending and cuts to safety net, but federal deficit would remain
Obamas' official portraits unveiled
Funeral recalls NFL player Edwin Jackson, killed in crash
Lincoln, Darwin: Same birthdate, vastly different lives
Winter Olympics day three – in pictures
Facebook is losing younger users to Snapchat, according to a study
If you're not watching women's hockey, you're missing out
Russia plane crash responders find 200 body parts
Mike Pence says U.S. ready to talk with North Korea
New York Attorney General Files a Lawsuit Against Harvey Weinstein
'Our Cartoon President': Meet the Voices Behind Trump and Co
London airport closed after WWII bomb discovered
Victoria Beckham bids farewell to New York fashion week on a high
The truth is out there! Hundreds of 'UFO and alien sightings' in UK reported to police
The Equifax Hack Exposed More Data Than Previously Reported
Conway on Porter's alleged abuse: 'I have no reason not to believe these women'
Prominent Pakistani rights activist Asma Jahangir dies aged 66
71 feared dead as Russian plane crashes near Moscow 
North Korea invite is dramatic gesture, but not diplomatic breakthrough
UFC 221 Results: Yoel Romero starches Luke Rockhold to move back into title contention
Vladimir Putin PLEAS with Israel's Netanyahu not go to WAR with Iran as conflict escalates
Siri on HomePod Correctly Answered 52.3% of Queries in New AI Test
Oscars: What's at Stake for the Best Picture Studios
Luther star Idris Elba to marry beauty queen Sabrina Dhowre
Yu Darvish, Cubs reach $126 million, 6-year deal
Watch Stephen Colbert Ask John Oliver Intimate Questions in His "Personal Space" Box
Composer Jóhann Jóhannsson dead at 48
'They are LIARS' Middle East tensions erupt as Israeli fighter jet attacked by Iran
Russia concerned by attacks in Syria, calls for restraint: Ministry
Ellen Pompeo on "Empowering" Decision to Reveal Her $20M Salary
Liam Neeson Auditions to Be Cupid in 'Late Show' Sketch
Should Zach LaVine's minute-restriction make way for the Bulls' winning restriction?
Paul Rudd and Jimmy Fallon Star in "King of Wishful Thinking" Music Video
The Olympics Opening Ceremony Drone Show Is Just So Damn Impressive
Israeli F-16 jet shot down by Syrian fire, military says
Kim Jong Un invites South Korean President Moon to Pyongyang
Here’s how to make the most out of National Pizza Day (yes, it’s a thing)
WhatsApp update lets you send MONEY within chat app
Constipation pain? This simple exercise could help get rid of bloating
Trump says he was 'surprised' by abuse allegations against staff secretary Rob Porter
What happened to the Tesla that Elon Musk shot into space?
How Elon Musk cleverly used the Starman to promote his car brand (Tesla)
Justin Timberlake Brings Selfie Kid To Tears With An Even Better Surprise
The best photos of the 2018 Winter Olympics
Pence and Kim Jong Un's sister sat meters from each other at the winter games' opening ceremony
Trudeau to Facebook: Fix your fake news problem or face stricter regulations
Kim Yo-jong arrives in South Korea: What we know about the North Korean ‘princess'
Senate votes to reopen government and boost spending; House vote looms
Qualcomm Rejects Broadcom's `Best and Final' $121 Billion Bid
Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau Really Wants Toronto to Get Amazon's Second Headquarters
Asteroid passing close to Earth today – no need to worry
What The White House Won’t Say About Rob Porter’s Exit
Chicago is bracing for its biggest snow since 2015
US issues security alert for Trinidad and Tobago Carnival
CNN Had Booked Holocaust-Denying Candidate On Multiple Shows
Coldest Winter Olympics in decades
Tom Hardy Venom movie trailer is coming TOMORROW: Confirmed! Will Spider-Man appear?
Bring 'food, snacks, patience' to Eagles parade, city officials say
Twitter just had its first profitable quarter
George W. Bush: It’s Pretty Clear That Russia Meddled In 2016 Election
Ending NAFTA Would Be Bad Politics And Bad For Americans: Trudeau
Here's what's next for SpaceX after Falcon Heavy's first flight
Nancy Pelosi tells US House immigrant stories for eight hours
South Korea's President Moon to meet Kim Jong Un's sister at Olympics
Russia to launch military satellite in WEEKS as Putin sends missiles to Baltic Sea
Kylie Jenner's Baby Stormi photo becomes the most liked photo on Instagram, surpassing Beyonce
Microsoft targets Box, Dropbox and Google customers with OneDrive offer
TV Ratings: 'This Is Us' Sees Minor Super Bowl Lift
First modern Britons had 'dark to black' skin, Cheddar Man DNA analysis reveals
100-million-year-old spider with a tail longer than its body discovered - and it may still be alive
Eiffel Tower closed as heavy snowfall blankets Paris
Snapchat overhaul convinces investors it can fight Instagram
Watch James Corden Show 'Fifty Shades' Star Jamie Dornan His "Playroom"
Trump: ‘I’d Love To See A Shutdown’ If Congress Doesn’t Agree On Immigration
Close