Close
Date TimeFebruary 02, 2018
Voice
When I was a homicide prosecutor in the Brooklyn District Attorney's office, my most challenging assignment was "riding" homicide cases. I'd get paged (often in the middle of the night) and a patrol car would pick me up and take me to the grisly scene of a recent murder.
If a suspect was in custody, it was my job to evaluate the evidence and authorize an arrest if one could be legally supported. I had to be careful because the case would be mine to prosecute before a jury. A mistake would put an innocent suspect in prison while the true murderer roamed free. The stakes were high.
Sometimes in cases of all kinds, as in the Carter Page matter currently at the center of the controversy over a GOP memo on FBI surveillance, a search or surveillance warrant requiring the approval of a judge is required to gather critical evidence.
I remember one night knocking on the door of an elegant Brooklyn Heights townhouse seeking such a warrant from a tough, respected judge at approximately one in the morning. I had tried many murder cases before this judge and I was hopeful she would grant a search warrant in my case. She looked a little angry when answering the door in her bathrobe with cigarette and scotch in hand.
After berating me for bothering her at such an hour, she scrutinized my warrant application. It was based on the observations of a drug addict who claimed to have seen the defendant return to his apartment gun in hand after the murder and then leave without the gun shortly thereafter. The addict was known to the cops and had provided reliable information in the past.
The judge wasn't happy about the quality of my witness, but she had been around long enough to know that witnesses in criminal cases often have credibility problems themselves. She granted us the warrant. A search of the suspect's apartment led to a recovered murder weapon and a conviction.
I learned that night that search and surveillance warrants are often issued on information supplied by even the sketchiest of sources. Unlike the street addicts whose testimony often sends criminal defendants to prison for life, the now-notorious Christopher Steele -- a former British intelligence agent -- appears to be, by comparison, a seasoned professional highly adept at gathering reliable information.
Even assuming all the claims in the Nunes memo are true, the grounds supporting issuance and reissuance of the FISA warrants were easily met. The FISA statute, designed to deal with national security issues, permits the secret court to authorize surveillance of a US person if there is probable cause that the person is an "agent of a foreign power...knowingly engag[ing]... in clandestine intelligence activities."
Although the activities might be "spying" for a foreign power, there is no explicit requirement of criminality needed to get a warrant as in a conventional criminal case. The number and suspicious nature of Carter Page's activities and contacts with Russian operatives during the Trump campaign would have caused any reasonable judge to issue a surveillance warrant. Page, a former Trump foreign policy adviser, denies having any illegal interactions with Russian officials.
The Supreme Court has stated that the issuance of a search warrant can be supported by the "totality of the circumstances" presented to the court at the time a warrant is issued.
The Nunes memo glaringly omits any revelation of what other supporting information might have been submitted to the FISA judge, choosing instead to focus on cherry-picked alleged omissions.
Many of the other criticisms hyped in the memo may not even be relevant at all. For instance, the claim that the judge was informed that Steele was paid by a named US citizen was accurate. The court was free to to ask the assistant US attorney submitting the Steele information any questions about whether others were involved in the payments. Nothing, incidentally, is revealed about questions from the judge.
Other points raised in the memo are interesting background material but would not render the surveillance warrant to be illegal in any way. There was no illegality in Steele talking to the press (Yahoo in this case) or even in the fact that he disliked Trump. That sentiment seems to be shared by a majority of the American public as the President in his first year earned historically low approval ratings.
It certainly would not require disqualification of an FBI source if the "totality of the circumstances" supported the warrant application.
The rest of the Nunes memo's criticisms that were purportedly earth-shattering, Watergate-like revelations are equally empty claims. The fact that the Steele dossier was "salacious and unverified" doesn't mean that the portions of it relating to Carter Page were untrue. The surveillance was authorized so that law enforcement authorities could confirm or deny through other evidence the accuracy of the claims against Page.
This was a case in its investigatory stage, not the finished product. Fusion GPS demonstrates the good sense to turn the Steele material over to the FBI ... in essence making a 911 call ... because as the Department of Homeland Security likes to remind us, "If you see something, say something."
The dossier on the President, whether true or false, could subject him to blackmail by foreign powers. The FBI was correct in telling the President about the threat, even if "salacious and unverified."
If there is anything shocking in the Nunes memo, it can be found in its faulty reasoning, writing and sourcing. The American public needs to know the "totality of circumstances" presented to the FISA judge in order to fairly evaluate the conduct of the DOJ and the FBI.
If I had presented such a document to that Brooklyn Heights judge so many years ago, she would have thrown me out of her house with no warrant and a stern reprimand. Congressman Nunes and his fellow Republicans deserve the same.

Related Stories
Pete Buttigieg calls Vice President Pence a cheerleader for the porn star presidencyPete Buttigieg calls Vice President Pence a 'cheerleader for the porn star presidency'
Tim Apple: Donald Trump gets name of tech giants CEO wrong'Tim Apple': Donald Trump gets name of tech giant's CEO wrong
New York attorney general is investigating Trump projectsNew York attorney general is investigating Trump projects
North Korea rocket site is being monitored in real time, U.S. official saysNorth Korea rocket site is being monitored 'in real time,' U.S. official says
Robert Mueller report will be a gold mine of improprieties. Trump shouldnt celebrate yetRobert Mueller report will be a gold mine of improprieties. Trump shouldn't celebrate yet
Trump to make $8.6 billion wall demand, triggering new standoff with CongressTrump to make $8.6 billion wall demand, triggering new standoff with Congress
Beto O’Rourke says he is running for US presidentBeto O’Rourke says he is running for US president
Jay Leno: Late-Night Shows Are Too PoliticalJay Leno: Late-Night Shows Are Too Political
Paul Manafort Sentenced To Less Than 4 Years In Prison In Mueller ProbePaul Manafort Sentenced To Less Than 4 Years In Prison In Mueller Probe
Trump to lift not necessary North Korea sanctions, White House confirmsTrump to lift 'not necessary' North Korea sanctions, White House confirms
News Trends
Tesla to Investigate Car That Appeared to Burst Into Flames in ShanghaiTesla to Investigate Car That Appeared to Burst Into Flames in Shanghai
Stephen Graham says This Is England role nearly ended his acting careerStephen Graham says This Is England role nearly ended his acting career
Maisie Williams could show as much or as little as she wanted in shocking Game of Thrones sex sceneMaisie Williams could show 'as much or as little' as she wanted in shocking 'Game of Thrones' sex scene
Sri Lanka Attacks: Asos Billionaire Loses Three Children In Easter Sunday BlastsSri Lanka Attacks: Asos Billionaire Loses Three Children In Easter Sunday Blasts
These 10 Democrats Want Trump ImpeachedThese 10 Democrats Want Trump Impeached
Rep. Seth Moulton Launches 2020 Presidential BidRep. Seth Moulton Launches 2020 Presidential Bid
Why observe Earth Day on April 22?Why observe Earth Day on April 22?
Beyoncé lands $60M deal with NetflixBeyoncé lands $60M deal with Netflix
Tesla’s Elon Musk could earn up to $2.2 billion from stock optionsTesla’s Elon Musk could earn up to $2.2 billion from stock options
Paris police use tear gas against yellow vest protestersParis police use tear gas against 'yellow vest' protesters
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Pete Buttigieg calls Vice President Pence a cheerleader for the porn star presidencyPete Buttigieg calls Vice President Pence a 'cheerleader for the porn star presidency'
Tim Apple: Donald Trump gets name of tech giants CEO wrong'Tim Apple': Donald Trump gets name of tech giant's CEO wrong
New York attorney general is investigating Trump projectsNew York attorney general is investigating Trump projects
North Korea rocket site is being monitored in real time, U.S. official saysNorth Korea rocket site is being monitored 'in real time,' U.S. official says
Robert Mueller report will be a gold mine of improprieties. Trump shouldnt celebrate yetRobert Mueller report will be a gold mine of improprieties. Trump shouldn't celebrate yet
Trump to make $8.6 billion wall demand, triggering new standoff with CongressTrump to make $8.6 billion wall demand, triggering new standoff with Congress
Beto O’Rourke says he is running for US presidentBeto O’Rourke says he is running for US president
Jay Leno: Late-Night Shows Are Too PoliticalJay Leno: Late-Night Shows Are Too Political
Paul Manafort Sentenced To Less Than 4 Years In Prison In Mueller ProbePaul Manafort Sentenced To Less Than 4 Years In Prison In Mueller Probe
Trump to lift not necessary North Korea sanctions, White House confirmsTrump to lift 'not necessary' North Korea sanctions, White House confirms
News Trends
Tesla to Investigate Car That Appeared to Burst Into Flames in ShanghaiTesla to Investigate Car That Appeared to Burst Into Flames in Shanghai
Stephen Graham says This Is England role nearly ended his acting careerStephen Graham says This Is England role nearly ended his acting career
Maisie Williams could show as much or as little as she wanted in shocking Game of Thrones sex sceneMaisie Williams could show 'as much or as little' as she wanted in shocking 'Game of Thrones' sex scene
Sri Lanka Attacks: Asos Billionaire Loses Three Children In Easter Sunday BlastsSri Lanka Attacks: Asos Billionaire Loses Three Children In Easter Sunday Blasts
These 10 Democrats Want Trump ImpeachedThese 10 Democrats Want Trump Impeached
Rep. Seth Moulton Launches 2020 Presidential BidRep. Seth Moulton Launches 2020 Presidential Bid
Why observe Earth Day on April 22?Why observe Earth Day on April 22?
Beyoncé lands $60M deal with NetflixBeyoncé lands $60M deal with Netflix
Tesla’s Elon Musk could earn up to $2.2 billion from stock optionsTesla’s Elon Musk could earn up to $2.2 billion from stock options
Paris police use tear gas against yellow vest protestersParis police use tear gas against 'yellow vest' protesters
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
In Natalie Wood case, we should stay away from Hollywood theories
'Nunes memo' published after Trump declassifies controversial document
James Corden, Stephen Colbert Debunk Trump's State of the Union Ratings Claim
Father lunges at Nassar in court before being restrained
Groundhog Day 2018: Punxsutawney Phil sees his shadow, 6 more weeks of winter
US Added 200000 Jobs in January; Wages Rise Most Since 2009
Trump Accuses His Justice Department, FBI Of Favoring Democrats
Devin Nunes is acting like he's in a spy thriller
Robert Wagner named 'person of interest' in Natalie Wood death investigation
Bitcoin price WARNING: ‘Will hit $50,000’ but end ‘really BADLY’ for investors says expert
Meghan Markle and Prince Harry suit up for first black tie engagement together
Trump to Democrats: Stop dragging your feet on DACA
Smoking Driver Hits Crowd In Shanghai After Accidentally Igniting Van
Hundreds of workers trapped in South African gold mine
4 students hit by gunfire at Los Angeles school; 12-year-old girl in custody
Frankfurt Airport bus crash - 13 Ryanair passengers injured in collision
'Huge explosion' in Ankara - smoke rises above Turkey capital
Laura Benanti's Melania Trump Responds to State Of the Union Address
Apple: All iPhones, iPads and Macs affected by chip flaws
West Ham suspend director of player recruitment Tony Henry amid racism claim
May in China LIVE: Brexit trade boost as its revealed Chinese nickname PM 'AUNTIE'
Tesla's Musk sells $10 million in flamethrowers in four days
Hope Hicks Told President That Trump Jr.‘s Emails ‘Will Never Get Out’: Report
Dorian Awards: 'Call Me by Your Name' Hailed as Film of the Year
Tomi Lahren Apologizes to Congressman for Vulgar Remarks
US missile defense test failed in Hawaii
Night photos that make Tokyo look like a sci-fi utopia
President Trump opts out of Super Bowl interview
Former NBA player Rasual Butler, 'American Idol' star killed in car crash
Michelle Obama finally reveals what Melania Trump gave her during awkward gift exchange
Chrissy Teigen Got on Her Knees and Called Beyonce a Queen at the Grammys
Train Carrying GOP Members Of Congress Collides With Truck
Equifax will offer free credit protection deal for five more months
Mesut Ozil: Real reason Arsenal star has agreed new contract revealed by reporter
One dead as strong earthquake rattles Afghanistan, Pakistan
Ivanka Trump wears £2520 tweed dress to State of the Union - it almost SELLS out across UK
The speech in 2 minutes
Redskins' trade for Alex Smith comes at significant cost
On China visit, Britain's May focused on post-Brexit future
Trump's State of the Union spoke to America's innovative, entrepreneurial spirit. Carpe diem, everyone
Stormy Daniels Joins Jimmy Kimmel for Post-'State of the Union' Guest Appearance
Cyrus Yavneh, Producer on '24,' 'Supernatural' and 'It's Pat: The Movie,' Dies at 76
The first lady's cream suit, kente cloth and purple ribbons: What the SOTU fashion choices meant
Kevin Towers, who guided the San Diego Padres to the World Series, dies at 56
Glee actor Mark Salling found dead aged 35
James Corden Fires Back at Critics of Hillary Clinton's Grammys Appearance
Andrea Tantaros Claims Female Fox News Employees Were Secretly Recorded Disrobing
Health experts urge Facebook to shut down Messenger Kids
Chris Christie Joining ABC News as a Contributor
Amazon, Berkshire, JPM team up for cheaper employee healthcare
More than 63 million women 'missing' in India, statistics show
What happened to the State of the Union address? Originally, it helped the president and Congress deliberate
Rihanna Celebrates Grammy Win With Rumored Billionaire Boyfriend
US releases list of Russian oligarchs, political figures
Melania Trump, out of sight since Stormy Daniels reports, will attend State of the Union
Stephen Colbert Weighs In on Grammys' Political Night
Kim Jong Nam met with mystery American
David Beckham announces launch of Miami MLS team – here’s all you need to know
Elon Musk sells $3.5m worth of flamethrowers in a day
FBI No. 2 official McCabe steps down amid Trump criticism: source
Russian fighter jet buzzes US spy plane in Black Sea, Navy says
Hackers invade YouTube ads to mine cryptocurrency
Angelina Jolie describes 'soul-destroying' visit to Syrian refugee camp
Rosenstein approved surveillance extension of former Trump adviser Carter Page
U.S. memo urges big push on 5G wireless technology, eyes China threat
Strava fitness tracking app reveals movements on remote military bases
Penelope Cruz to Get Honorary Cesar Award
'Babylon Berlin' Takes Top Honors at German TV Awards
Grammys 2018: Janelle Monáe Addresses 'Time's Up' Movement In Empowering Speech
Grammys 2018 take on Trump, DACA and gender equality as Bruno Mars takes home Album of the Year
Grammys: Alessia Cara Wins Best New Artist
Nikki Haley wants politics out of her Grammy awards
Donald Trump hits back at Jay-Z over race record even as aides promise a more conciliatory tone in State of the Union address
Five dead in Pennsylvania shooting rampage
'Lady Macbeth' Director William Oldroyd Adapting 'Chimerica' for U.K.'s Channel 4
Putin critic arrested in nationwide protests
Iranian-American imprisoned in Iran given 4-day leave after hospitalization
Ikea founder Ingvar Kamprad dies aged 91
Trump says he would negotiate Brexit with 'tougher' attitude than Theresa May
Prince Harry's ex-girlfriend Cressida Bonas posts racy snap after Meghan Markle engagement
'SNL': Will Ferrell Reprises George W. Bush Impression in Cold Open
Facebook And Google’s Surveillance Capitalism Model Is In Trouble
Canada's Bombardier gets big win over Boeing
Space X to launch world's most powerful rocket
At least 5 police officers killed in Colombia bombing
Rolex 24 has coolness factor, Daytona charm and more
Paris on flooding high alert as swollen River Seine set to rise further 
Italy: 800 migrants rescued, 2 bodies found in Mediterranean
Sean Hannity's Twitter account is deactivated
Caroline Wozniacki wins Australian Open title after epic battle with Halep
Three teenagers dead after car crashes into west London bus stop
Saudi billionaire Prince Alwaleed released as corruption probe winds down
Russia's opposition leader: Putin regime 'built on corruption'
Taliban attacker driving ambulance packed with explosives kills 40 in Kabul
US preparing for WAR in SPACE with China or Russia says Trump Defence Secretary Jim Mattis
Acid attack epidemic: RECORD number of incidents in London last year, data reveals
'Salyut-7' Awarded Best Russian Movie at Golden Eagles Ceremony
Report: RNC Finance Chair Steve Wynn Accused Of Decades Of Sexual Misconduct
US official warns Hong Kong over North Korea smuggling
Davos: Bitcoin is not a currency
BREAKING: Amsterdam GUN ATTACK – At least one dead and two hurt in Netherlands shooting
Hillary Clinton Chose to Shield a Top Adviser Accused of Harassment in 2008
Paris is still on flood alert even though rain has stopped
Nikki Haley denies Trump affair rumors
India Republic Day 2018 in pictures: Massive military parade, motorbike stunts and camels
Nutella CRISIS: France descends into CHAOS with RIOTS after sale
You’ve got FOUR WEEKS! Brussels issues Brexit trade deadline to Theresa May
Roger Federer reaches seventh Australian Open final as Hyeon Chung retires
Tesla denies further Model 3 production issues
Casey Affleck withdraws from presenting best-actress award at Oscars
Trump wanted Mueller fired back in June, reports say
James Corden Says Grammys Will Include #MeToo Moment
Stormy Daniels Set to Appear on 'Jimmy Kimmel Live!'
White House proposes path to citizenship for 1.8 million people
Deadliest fire in 10 years kills 39 in South Korean hospital
The White House 'requested a Van Gogh, but got a golden toilet instead'
What is the Doomsday Clock? Why has the dreaded clock moved closer to midnight TODAY?
'We'll talk about it' Donald Trump reveals visit to Britain could still go ahead
First lady Melania Trump skips Davos, goes to Holocaust memorial in Washington
5.8 earthquake strikes off Northern California coast. No tsunami threat
Lisa Kudrow Recalls Not Recognizing Jane Fonda
Who is Virginia Woolf? Google Doodle honours English book author’s 136th birthday
Captain Cook statue VANDALISED: Protests mount ahead of Australia Day
Trump, in Davos, Hopes to Sell the Story of US Success
Oprah Shuts Down 2020 Presidential Run Rumors
Meryl Streep joins 'Big Little Lies' Season 2
BREAKING: Train derails in horrific rush-hour crash in Milan - fatalities reported
Trump seeks $25 billion for border wall, offers 'Dreamer' citizenship
Google Parent Alphabet Announces New Cybersecurity Firm
Megyn Kelly's Jane Fonda Jab May Cost 'Today' Star Bookings
Trump 'looking forward' to going under oath
Julian Assange's health in 'dangerous' condition, say doctors
Bitcoin news: Arsenal signs cryptocurrency deal in world first
One reason Netflix users might want to buy a Google Home instead of an Amazon Echo
WATCH: Theresa May 'FALLS ASLEEP' as PM and Hammond mock Corbyn's tiresome NHS argument
Country singer Lari White dead at 52 after short cancer battle
The iOS 11.3 developer beta is available for download right now
Monkey see, monkey 2: Scientists clone monkeys using technique that created Dolly the sheep
Larry Nassar sentenced to up to 175 years in prison for decades of sexual misconduct
Roger Federer overpowers Tomas Berdych to set up Hyeon Chung meeting in Australian Open semi-finals
Toys R Us closing 180 stores: Full list of store closures planned in huge restructure
Alaska earthquake: 78 quakes hit gulf near Kodiak after 7.9 shock sparks tsunami warning
Late-Night Hosts Weigh In on Oscar Nominee Snubs, Surprises
Car bomb attack near Benghazi mosque kills 34
'This Is Us:' Jack's cause of death revealed and fans are heartbroken
’Social media cryptocurrency’ will allow users to earn money for Facebook 'likes'
Facebook acquires biometric ID verification startup Confirm.io
TV Writers Launch Anonymous Pay Survey Amid Push for Salary Parity
Ursula K. Le Guin, famed science fiction and fantasy writer, dies at 88
Haley, Tillerson call out Russia on Syria's chemical weapons use
Two students dead, 12 others wounded by gunfire in Kentucky high school shooting
See the full list of 2018 Oscar nominees
Alaska earthquake: Terrifying graphic reveals true extent of TSUNAMI DANGER
Musk may get no salary unless Tesla hits milestones
Tsunami warnings canceled after magnitude-7.9 earthquake off Alaska
Peace between Israel and Palestinians 'more possible' after Jerusalem move, Pence says
Hugh Masekela, South African jazz legend, dies at age 78
BREAKING: Fireball engulfs TRAIN in deadly flames after horror crash with 'ethanol truck'
Neil Diamond announces Parkinson's diagnosis, immediate retirement
Man arrested over threats to 'gun down' CNN employees: report
'Conan': People of Haiti Roast President Trump in Preview Clip
Hijab-wearing model pulls out of L'Oreal campaign over 2014 tweets
Facebook, Google promote 'scurrilous' news, and should pay for quality content, said Rupert Murdoch
US shutdown to end as Senate Republicans and Democrats reach a deal
Megyn Kelly Lambasts Jane Fonda: Her "Name Is Synonymous With Outrage"
'Vampirina' Gets Second Season at Disney Junior
Jerusalem Embassy Move Will Happen Next Year, VP Pence Says
BREAKING: Another royal wedding as Princess Eugenie confirms ENGAGEMENT to Jack Brooksbank
France's Macron hosts 140 world business leaders
Philippines Raises Alert Level as Mayon Volcano Eruption Intensifies
Prince Harry SECRETLY introduces Meghan Markle to ‘very significant person’ in his life
Apple makes significant investment in Malala's education fund
Amazon Go app hits Google Play just ahead of Seattle store opening
SAG Awards: Rosanna Arquette, Marisa Tomei Give Emotional Tribute to Women of #MeToo
Star of popular North Korean girl band visits South Korea ahead of Olympic performances
Macron: French would 'probably' back a 'Frexit'
Thousands join Women's March in London for gender equality
Jim Johannson, US Olympic men’s hockey general manager, dies unexpectedly at age 53
'SNL': Kate McKinnon Debuts Robert Mueller Impersonation
Pence says immigration talks over until government reopens
America planned to bring Russia in from the cold with Star Wars project
Julie Neville: How I healed myself with superfoods
Sign of alien life? Mysterious phenomenon spotted in skies above Japan
Ivanka Trump ‘will follow father Donald Trump as US President by 2032’
The Latest: Taliban kill 18 militiamen in Afghanistan
Natalie Portman, Alfre Woodard, Olivia Munn and more bring Time's Up fire to Women's March in L.A
Prague hotel fire: At least two dead and seven injured after horror blaze engulfs hotel
Trump Blames Democrats For Government Shutdown In Morning Tweets
'This is about equality': Activists take to the streets for Women's March
'The Crown': Paul Bettany Near Deal to Play Prince Philip
Turkish jets hit Kurdish positions in northern Syria
Tom Petty died of accidental drug overdose, says family
Santa Barbara Film Fest: Margot Robbie, Allison Janney to Share Performer Award
Everything you need to know about women's marches this weekend
Facebook to start 'trust ratings' for media outlets as it fights back against fake news
REVEALED: This is where World War 3 will break out – and it is NOT North Korea
U.S. government shutdown begins as spending bill fails in Senate
Supreme Court to decide legality of Trump travel ban
Watch Al Pacino in First Trailer for HBO's 'Paterno'
White House officials say they're preparing for "Schumer shutdown"
Close