Close
Date TimeJanuary 27, 2018
VoiceA new era of internet regulation is about to begin.
Years after Facebook and Google went public, regulators in the United States and abroad are finally taking a closer look at the internet behemoths. And they’re not only looking at the way these companies have come to dominate markets, but also examining the heart of the two firms’ business models. What they decide will have powerful implications for the way we do business on the internet.
Most people associate Facebook with cute family photos and think of Google like a semi-reliable encyclopedia. But these services have only a tangential relationship to the way either company actually makes money. The twin Silicon Valley titans rely on two closely intertwined technologies, customer surveillance and advertising, to maximize shareholder profits. The pair control 63 percent of the U.S. digital advertising market, and in 2016, they secured 99 percent of all digital advertising growth. That profit-making combo is exactly what regulators are focused on in 2018.
Many of the companies’ difficulties stem from the European Union’s tough new stance on privacy. The biggest threat to their business model comes from the General Data Protection Regulation, new data privacy rules set to go in effect in the EU in May. For the most part, Facebook and Google prevent you from using their products if you decline to agree to their entire terms of service. You cannot pick and choose what to agree to and still use their free services.
The GDPR changes that by requiring online companies, in some cases, to get permission from each individual user to collect, share and combine their data for use by advertisers. Companies will not be allowed to ban people from their services who decline to share their data for advertising purposes. There are 734 million EU residents who will soon be able to opt out of helping Facebook and Google make money. If companies do not comply with the new regulations they will face fines totaling four percent of their global revenues.
“These laws and regulations, as well as any associated inquiries or investigations or any other government actions, may be costly to comply with and may delay or impede the development of new products, result in negative publicity, increase our operating costs, require significant management time and attention, and subject us to remedies that may harm our business, including fines or demands or orders that we modify or cease existing business practices,” Facebook stated in its most recent quarterly Securities and Exchange Commission filing.
But GDPR isn’t the only trouble ahead for Facebook and Google. There are also myriad investigations underway into allegedly abusive practices by the firms.
After fining Google a record $2.8 billion in 2017 for prioritizing its own products over competitors in its online search results, the EU’s competition commission continues to investigate the company for allegedly abusing its market dominance in the mobile phone market through its Android operating system. Germany’s antitrust commission issued a preliminary report in December stating that Facebook uses its dominant position to place unfair conditions on its users by combining data from the Facebook main site with data retrieved from third party sources through its “like” button. In December, France gave Facebook one month to stop combining data from its WhatsApp platform with its Facebook platform without user consent or face sanctions and fines. Ireland’s antitrust enforcer has also investigated Facebook for sharing WhatsApp data without user consent.
Facebook And Google’s Surveillance Capitalism Model Is In Trouble
In the U.S., Congress continues to hold hearings on the use of Google and Facebook platforms ― including Instagram and YouTube ― by Russian trolls and international and domestic terrorists to recruit new members, spread their messages and disrupt U.S. elections. Missouri Attorney General Josh Hawley, a Republican, has also launched his own investigation into whether Google is in violation U.S. antitrust laws.
For the first time, the online business model of surveillance capitalism is coming under the microscope. But it didn’t have to be this way in the first place.

How Facebook And Google’s Surveillance Model Came To Own The Internet
The business model that we all submit to when we unthinkingly click “Agree” on those lengthy terms of service agreements, or plug in that Google Home or Amazon Alexa your parents bought you for Christmas, was not a foregone conclusion when commerce went online back in the 1990s. It came about from a lack of options and a need to show profitability to investors.
In the mid-1990s, businesses and news organizations used the traditional advertising model for content production previously used by television, newspapers and magazines when they went online. It seemed to be the only way to show profits to venture capital investors or corporate managers.
At the time, there was no secure way to transmit payments online, making a subscription model impossible. Advertising was the only option.
Wired magazine debuted its online site HotWired in 1994 and with it the very first banner ad, courtesy of AT&T. “A lot of the things that we did, and that we’re credited for, were really not brilliant decisions, they were constraints,” then-Chief Technology Officer for Wired Andrew Anker told the Internet Podcast in 2014, while noting the lack of secured payment technologies for credit cards at the time. “We had no choice.”
Ethan Zuckerman, the director of the Center for Civic Media at MIT, was one of these early web pioneers. As one of the co-founders of the venture capital backed Tripod.com, he had to show his investors that the company could pull in some kind of revenue. Everything failed except advertising and the attendant surveillance of users that could be harvested for marketing data.
There were problems, of course. One Tripod.com advertiser complained about their material appearing on a page celebrating anal sex. The solution Zuckerman came up with was to make the ad open in a different window when it loaded. He had created the much-loathed pop-up ad.
Zuckerman regrets the decisions he and the early web entrepreneurs made that paved the path to the widespread surveillance of human behavior by private corporations. In a 2014 essay for The Atlantic, he labeled this the ”Internet’s Original Sin.”
“I think we took the easy way out frankly,” he told HuffPost. “I think we should have been charging for services. We didn’t consider this idea that we were going to end up putting users under surveillance.”
But that’s what happened. Advertising became the predominant source of revenue for all of the early large-scale search engines. Tech entrepreneur Bill Gross even launched a purely ad-based search engine in 1998 that showed search results solely based on who paid the most money to get to the top.
Google founders Larry Page and Sergey Brin found the advertising models distasteful. In a 1998 academic article for Stanford, the duo detailed their search engine and explained the problems with search engine advertising. “The goals of the advertising business model do not always correspond to providing quality search to users,” they wrote. ”[W]e expect that advertising funded search engines will be inherently biased towards the advertisers and away from the needs of the consumers.”
Page and Brin eventually came around to funding their wildly popular search engine with an entirely new form of advertising. Instead of bombarding users with as many ads as possible, Google would use its access to user searches to tailor advertising to them based on what they were looking for at that very moment. They’d target users with fewer, more specifically tailored advertisements through their AdWords platform. Later, they’d expand their advertising program by purchasing their biggest competition, DoubleClick.
Facebook And Google’s Surveillance Capitalism Model Is In Trouble
Mark Zuckerberg also launched Facebook with a disdain for intrusive advertising, but it wasn’t long before the social network giant became Google’s biggest competitor for ad dollars. After going public with 845 million users in 2012, Facebook became a multibillion-dollar company and Zuckerberg one of the richest men on Earth, but with only a promise that the company would figure out how to monetize its platform.
Facebook ultimately sold companies on its platform by promising “brand awareness” and the best possible data on what consumers actually liked. Brands could start their own Facebook pages, which people would actually “like” and interact with. This provided unparalleled information about what company each individual person wanted to interact with the most. By engaging with companies on Facebook, people gave corporate marketing departments more information than they could have ever dreamed of buying, but here it was offered up free.
This was the “grand bargain,” as Columbia University law professor Tim Wu called it in his book, The Attention Merchants, that users struck with corporations. Wu wrote that Facebook’s “billions of users worldwide were simply handing over a treasure trove of detailed demographic data and exposing themselves to highly targeted advertising in return for what, exactly?”
In other words: We will give you every detail of our lives and you will get rich by selling that information to advertisers.
European regulators are now saying that bargain was a bad deal. The big question that remains is whether their counterparts in the U.S. will follow their lead.

Related Stories
Pi day: What is Pi Day? How have Google broken a world record for Pi?Pi day: What is Pi Day? How have Google broken a world record for Pi?
Facebook only cares about privacy because it has toFacebook only cares about privacy because it has to
Google adds Snake to Maps for April Fools Day gagGoogle adds Snake to Maps for April Fools' Day gag
Here’s how you’ll access Google’s Stadia cloud gaming serviceHere’s how you’ll access Google’s Stadia cloud gaming service
Facebook investors launch desperate bid to oust Mark ZuckerbergFacebook investors launch desperate bid to oust Mark Zuckerberg
Jared Kushner dubs Trump-Russia investigation a big distractionJared Kushner dubs Trump-Russia investigation 'a big distraction'
News Trends
Lyra McKee funeral: politicians urged to seize the momentLyra McKee funeral: politicians urged to seize the moment
The Greta Thunberg effect: her activism in London in two minutes - videoThe Greta Thunberg effect: her activism in London in two minutes - video
Jennifer Garner thinks her face on cover of Peoples Beautiful Issue is so ridiculousJennifer Garner thinks her face on cover of People's Beautiful Issue is 'so ridiculous'
Rapper Bun B Shoots Armed Robber in His Houston HomeRapper Bun B Shoots Armed Robber in His Houston Home
SpaceX Crew Dragon Accident Another Bump in the Road for Commercial CrewSpaceX Crew Dragon Accident Another Bump in the Road for Commercial Crew
Meghan Markle and Prince Harry wrote a sweet birthday message for Prince Louis, but some people think it broke royal protocolMeghan Markle and Prince Harry wrote a sweet birthday message for Prince Louis, but some people think it broke royal protocol
Elon Musk told this Reddit user they should interview at Tesla, heres whyElon Musk told this Reddit user they 'should interview at Tesla', here's why
‘His career was incredible’. Billy McNeill was a winner as player and manager‘His career was incredible’. Billy McNeill was a winner as player and manager
Natalie Portman makes a surprise appearance at the Avengers: Endgame premiereNatalie Portman makes a surprise appearance at the Avengers: Endgame premiere
Seahawks, Chiefs blow up NFL draft with Frank Clark tradeSeahawks, Chiefs blow up NFL draft with Frank Clark trade
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Pi day: What is Pi Day? How have Google broken a world record for Pi?Pi day: What is Pi Day? How have Google broken a world record for Pi?
Facebook only cares about privacy because it has toFacebook only cares about privacy because it has to
Google adds Snake to Maps for April Fools Day gagGoogle adds Snake to Maps for April Fools' Day gag
Here’s how you’ll access Google’s Stadia cloud gaming serviceHere’s how you’ll access Google’s Stadia cloud gaming service
Facebook investors launch desperate bid to oust Mark ZuckerbergFacebook investors launch desperate bid to oust Mark Zuckerberg
Jared Kushner dubs Trump-Russia investigation a big distractionJared Kushner dubs Trump-Russia investigation 'a big distraction'
News Trends
Lyra McKee funeral: politicians urged to seize the momentLyra McKee funeral: politicians urged to seize the moment
The Greta Thunberg effect: her activism in London in two minutes - videoThe Greta Thunberg effect: her activism in London in two minutes - video
Jennifer Garner thinks her face on cover of Peoples Beautiful Issue is so ridiculousJennifer Garner thinks her face on cover of People's Beautiful Issue is 'so ridiculous'
Rapper Bun B Shoots Armed Robber in His Houston HomeRapper Bun B Shoots Armed Robber in His Houston Home
SpaceX Crew Dragon Accident Another Bump in the Road for Commercial CrewSpaceX Crew Dragon Accident Another Bump in the Road for Commercial Crew
Meghan Markle and Prince Harry wrote a sweet birthday message for Prince Louis, but some people think it broke royal protocolMeghan Markle and Prince Harry wrote a sweet birthday message for Prince Louis, but some people think it broke royal protocol
Elon Musk told this Reddit user they should interview at Tesla, heres whyElon Musk told this Reddit user they 'should interview at Tesla', here's why
‘His career was incredible’. Billy McNeill was a winner as player and manager‘His career was incredible’. Billy McNeill was a winner as player and manager
Natalie Portman makes a surprise appearance at the Avengers: Endgame premiereNatalie Portman makes a surprise appearance at the Avengers: Endgame premiere
Seahawks, Chiefs blow up NFL draft with Frank Clark tradeSeahawks, Chiefs blow up NFL draft with Frank Clark trade
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Canada's Bombardier gets big win over Boeing
Space X to launch world's most powerful rocket
At least 5 police officers killed in Colombia bombing
Rolex 24 has coolness factor, Daytona charm and more
Paris on flooding high alert as swollen River Seine set to rise further 
Italy: 800 migrants rescued, 2 bodies found in Mediterranean
Sean Hannity's Twitter account is deactivated
Caroline Wozniacki wins Australian Open title after epic battle with Halep
Three teenagers dead after car crashes into west London bus stop
Saudi billionaire Prince Alwaleed released as corruption probe winds down
Russia's opposition leader: Putin regime 'built on corruption'
Taliban attacker driving ambulance packed with explosives kills 40 in Kabul
US preparing for WAR in SPACE with China or Russia says Trump Defence Secretary Jim Mattis
Acid attack epidemic: RECORD number of incidents in London last year, data reveals
'Salyut-7' Awarded Best Russian Movie at Golden Eagles Ceremony
Report: RNC Finance Chair Steve Wynn Accused Of Decades Of Sexual Misconduct
US official warns Hong Kong over North Korea smuggling
Davos: Bitcoin is not a currency
BREAKING: Amsterdam GUN ATTACK – At least one dead and two hurt in Netherlands shooting
Hillary Clinton Chose to Shield a Top Adviser Accused of Harassment in 2008
Paris is still on flood alert even though rain has stopped
Nikki Haley denies Trump affair rumors
India Republic Day 2018 in pictures: Massive military parade, motorbike stunts and camels
Nutella CRISIS: France descends into CHAOS with RIOTS after sale
You’ve got FOUR WEEKS! Brussels issues Brexit trade deadline to Theresa May
Roger Federer reaches seventh Australian Open final as Hyeon Chung retires
Tesla denies further Model 3 production issues
Casey Affleck withdraws from presenting best-actress award at Oscars
Trump wanted Mueller fired back in June, reports say
James Corden Says Grammys Will Include #MeToo Moment
Stormy Daniels Set to Appear on 'Jimmy Kimmel Live!'
White House proposes path to citizenship for 1.8 million people
Deadliest fire in 10 years kills 39 in South Korean hospital
The White House 'requested a Van Gogh, but got a golden toilet instead'
What is the Doomsday Clock? Why has the dreaded clock moved closer to midnight TODAY?
'We'll talk about it' Donald Trump reveals visit to Britain could still go ahead
First lady Melania Trump skips Davos, goes to Holocaust memorial in Washington
5.8 earthquake strikes off Northern California coast. No tsunami threat
Lisa Kudrow Recalls Not Recognizing Jane Fonda
Who is Virginia Woolf? Google Doodle honours English book author’s 136th birthday
Captain Cook statue VANDALISED: Protests mount ahead of Australia Day
Trump, in Davos, Hopes to Sell the Story of US Success
Oprah Shuts Down 2020 Presidential Run Rumors
Meryl Streep joins 'Big Little Lies' Season 2
BREAKING: Train derails in horrific rush-hour crash in Milan - fatalities reported
Trump seeks $25 billion for border wall, offers 'Dreamer' citizenship
Google Parent Alphabet Announces New Cybersecurity Firm
Megyn Kelly's Jane Fonda Jab May Cost 'Today' Star Bookings
Trump 'looking forward' to going under oath
Julian Assange's health in 'dangerous' condition, say doctors
Bitcoin news: Arsenal signs cryptocurrency deal in world first
One reason Netflix users might want to buy a Google Home instead of an Amazon Echo
WATCH: Theresa May 'FALLS ASLEEP' as PM and Hammond mock Corbyn's tiresome NHS argument
Country singer Lari White dead at 52 after short cancer battle
The iOS 11.3 developer beta is available for download right now
Monkey see, monkey 2: Scientists clone monkeys using technique that created Dolly the sheep
Larry Nassar sentenced to up to 175 years in prison for decades of sexual misconduct
Roger Federer overpowers Tomas Berdych to set up Hyeon Chung meeting in Australian Open semi-finals
Toys R Us closing 180 stores: Full list of store closures planned in huge restructure
Alaska earthquake: 78 quakes hit gulf near Kodiak after 7.9 shock sparks tsunami warning
Late-Night Hosts Weigh In on Oscar Nominee Snubs, Surprises
Car bomb attack near Benghazi mosque kills 34
'This Is Us:' Jack's cause of death revealed and fans are heartbroken
’Social media cryptocurrency’ will allow users to earn money for Facebook 'likes'
Facebook acquires biometric ID verification startup Confirm.io
TV Writers Launch Anonymous Pay Survey Amid Push for Salary Parity
Ursula K. Le Guin, famed science fiction and fantasy writer, dies at 88
Haley, Tillerson call out Russia on Syria's chemical weapons use
Two students dead, 12 others wounded by gunfire in Kentucky high school shooting
See the full list of 2018 Oscar nominees
Alaska earthquake: Terrifying graphic reveals true extent of TSUNAMI DANGER
Musk may get no salary unless Tesla hits milestones
Tsunami warnings canceled after magnitude-7.9 earthquake off Alaska
Peace between Israel and Palestinians 'more possible' after Jerusalem move, Pence says
Hugh Masekela, South African jazz legend, dies at age 78
BREAKING: Fireball engulfs TRAIN in deadly flames after horror crash with 'ethanol truck'
Neil Diamond announces Parkinson's diagnosis, immediate retirement
Man arrested over threats to 'gun down' CNN employees: report
'Conan': People of Haiti Roast President Trump in Preview Clip
Hijab-wearing model pulls out of L'Oreal campaign over 2014 tweets
Facebook, Google promote 'scurrilous' news, and should pay for quality content, said Rupert Murdoch
US shutdown to end as Senate Republicans and Democrats reach a deal
Megyn Kelly Lambasts Jane Fonda: Her "Name Is Synonymous With Outrage"
'Vampirina' Gets Second Season at Disney Junior
Jerusalem Embassy Move Will Happen Next Year, VP Pence Says
BREAKING: Another royal wedding as Princess Eugenie confirms ENGAGEMENT to Jack Brooksbank
France's Macron hosts 140 world business leaders
Philippines Raises Alert Level as Mayon Volcano Eruption Intensifies
Prince Harry SECRETLY introduces Meghan Markle to ‘very significant person’ in his life
Apple makes significant investment in Malala's education fund
Amazon Go app hits Google Play just ahead of Seattle store opening
SAG Awards: Rosanna Arquette, Marisa Tomei Give Emotional Tribute to Women of #MeToo
Star of popular North Korean girl band visits South Korea ahead of Olympic performances
Macron: French would 'probably' back a 'Frexit'
Thousands join Women's March in London for gender equality
Jim Johannson, US Olympic men’s hockey general manager, dies unexpectedly at age 53
'SNL': Kate McKinnon Debuts Robert Mueller Impersonation
Pence says immigration talks over until government reopens
America planned to bring Russia in from the cold with Star Wars project
Julie Neville: How I healed myself with superfoods
Sign of alien life? Mysterious phenomenon spotted in skies above Japan
Ivanka Trump ‘will follow father Donald Trump as US President by 2032’
The Latest: Taliban kill 18 militiamen in Afghanistan
Natalie Portman, Alfre Woodard, Olivia Munn and more bring Time's Up fire to Women's March in L.A
Prague hotel fire: At least two dead and seven injured after horror blaze engulfs hotel
Trump Blames Democrats For Government Shutdown In Morning Tweets
'This is about equality': Activists take to the streets for Women's March
'The Crown': Paul Bettany Near Deal to Play Prince Philip
Turkish jets hit Kurdish positions in northern Syria
Tom Petty died of accidental drug overdose, says family
Santa Barbara Film Fest: Margot Robbie, Allison Janney to Share Performer Award
Everything you need to know about women's marches this weekend
Facebook to start 'trust ratings' for media outlets as it fights back against fake news
REVEALED: This is where World War 3 will break out – and it is NOT North Korea
U.S. government shutdown begins as spending bill fails in Senate
Supreme Court to decide legality of Trump travel ban
Watch Al Pacino in First Trailer for HBO's 'Paterno'
White House officials say they're preparing for "Schumer shutdown"
Kim and Kanye reveal baby girl's name: Chicago West
Jimmy Kimmel Ask Kids About Trump's First Year in Office
Olympian Aly Raisman tells Nassar in court: 'The tables have turned, Larry'
Vladimir Putin takes icy plunge to mark Orthodox Epiphany
Ivanka Trump channels step-mother Melania in Pennsylvania with father Donald
Apple HomePod release date may be near, rumors say
Let's Build a Bridge to Europe After We Brexit, Britain's Boris Johnson Suggests
Powerful storm kills 6 in Europe
Peter Mayle, author of A Year in Provence, dies aged 78
Copacabana beach HORROR: Baby killed and 14 people injured as car ploughs into pedestrians
Stephen Colbert Enlists 'Magic School Bus' to Examine Trump's Health
Parents Charged With Torture And Abuse Of 13 Children Face Life In Prison
Kim Kardashian Slams Lamar Odom’s Mean Interview About Khloe In Just 5 Words
New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern reveals she is pregnant
Let's be honest about Aziz Ansari
'Party of Five' Reboot From Original Series Creators Lands at Freeform
Tomb Raider movie trailer: NEW teaser lands for Alicia Vikander’s Lara Croft
Britain to give France £44.5million for border controls amid fury at Le Touquet agreement
Theresa May and Emmanuel Macron to hold press conference at summit - Politics live
Amazon names top 20 finalists in second headquarters race
Trump says position on border wall 'has never changed or evolved'
Actor Peter Wyngarde, star of Department S, dies aged 90
Chris Tarrant admits drink-driving after police called when pub staff saw him stumble at bar
Exclusive: Trump denies U.S. embassy to be moved to Jerusalem within a year
Ivanka Trump beams as she wears black velvet power suit to ‘Women of America’ talk
Trump’s Fake News Awards Immediately Backfire, Take Down GOP Website
John Kelly: Trump Won’t Build Wall Along Entire U.S.-Mexico Border
Brexit bill passes final stage
Donald Trump ATTACKS Russia for ‘DENTING’ progress with North Korea in stinging assault
'Get Out' Star Daniel Kaluuya on "Weird Stuff" Said by White People
Eric Trump: My dad isn’t racist because he only ‘sees 1 color, green’
Electric bicycles emerge as a hot trend in the U.S
Pope ATTACKED: Shocking moment object hits Francis in face in Chile backlash
7 Netflix Shows To Watch If You Like ‘Friends’
6 teen suicides in 6 months in 1 Ohio school district
Australian Actress Jessica Falkholt Dies at 29 — Weeks After Car Crash Killed Her Family
Ex-CIA Officer Suspected of Compromising Chinese Informants Is Arrested
Late-Night Hosts Poke Fun at Trump's Physical Exam
US, Japan warn North Korea playing for time as talks press on
21 states sue to keep net neutrality as Senate Democrats reach 50 votes
Matt Damon apologizes for #MeToo comments, says he's shutting up now
Fox News shelved story on Trump and porn actress Stormy Daniels before election
Jane Fonda Jokes About Awkward Megyn Kelly Interview in Latest 'Today' Appearance
YouTube assigning workers to review videos to avoid another Logan Paul-type disaster
Greece earthquake MAP: Where have magnitude 4.3 Athens tremors struck in Greece?
Paris bus fire - vehicle packed with 30 passengers bursts into flames in French capital
Larry King says Princess Diana would have seen Meghan Markle as a 'step forward' for the monarchy
Kim Kardashian West welcomes third child
Veteran BBC broadcaster Ed Doolan dies aged 76
NAACP Awards 2018: The winners list
Amazon Echo Spot release - Cute smart speaker arrives in UK and here’s how to get £40 off
47 children injured in school bus crash in Germany - 10 in serious condition
Too old for DACA, man who spent 30 years of his life in U.S. is deported
Juan Williams: The case for Oprah
Trump breaks with past presidents on MLK Day activities
'Oh Happy Day' gospel singer Edwin Hawkins dies aged 74
Officials Warned Jared Kushner About Friendship With Wendi Deng Murdoch: Report
13 siblings ‘held captive’ by parents, some in chains and starving, police say
Russia's hidden world of North Korean labor
Lincoln, Honda, and Volvo winners at 2018 NAIAS
Dolores O’Riordan, lead singer of The Cranberries, dead at age 46
BREAKING: Athens in chaos - Police fire TEAR GAS as protestors hurl petrol bombs
Bali volcano eruption update: Mount Agung and Mount Sinabung spew smoke and ash into sky
Martin Luther King Jr.’s words continue to inspire, nearly 50 years after his death
Vogue publisher drops Bruce Weber and Mario Testino over misconduct allegations
Computers are getting better than humans at reading
Thousands of jobs at risk as Carillion goes into liquidation
Russia will not support U.S. attempts to change Iran nuclear deal: Lavrov
Brit Party Leader Splits With Girlfriend After Her Shocking Remarks About Meghan Markle
Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu in India to Deepen Links
Vancouver police concerned after ‘brazen’ shooting injures three, including bystanders
BREAKING: North Korea showdown with South begins as rival start talks over Winter Olympics
'Communism like Christianity and Lenin is a SAINT' claims Putin in shocking interview
Trump Insists He’s The ‘Least Racist Person’
140 women have accused Larry Nassar of abuse. His victims think we don’t care
Mark Zuckerberg Lost $3.3 Billion After Announcing Changes To Facebook's News Feed
Liverpool 4-3 Manchester City: Reds hold on at Anfield
How to mine bitcoin: A guide to bitcoin mining at home - Could YOU become a bitcoin miner?
Emily Thornberry: Donald Trump Is A 'Racist' And An 'Asteroid Of Awfulness', Says Labour's Shadow Foreign Secretary
Oprah Winfrey Asks Powerful Hollywood Women About Woody Allen in Time's Up Interview
Peru earthquake: 2 dead, at least 65 injured
Bobby Zarin of 'Real Housewives' dead at 71
Close