Close
Date TimeDecember 02, 2017
VoiceInstead of wasting the resources on preparing for more talks, America’s diplomats and strategic planners can focus on improving its deterrence against North Korea and let it be China’s problem, writes Bloomberg’s Eli Lake.



U.S. Ambassador Nikki Haley’s remarks this week at the United Nations after North Korea’s latest missile test sounded like what a superpower should say: If war comes, “the North Korean regime will be utterly destroyed.” If China doesn’t cut off oil to the Hermit Kingdom, “we can take the oil situation into our own hands.”
It would have been a great speech in 1997. That was when signatories to the nuclear non-proliferation treaty were loath to violate it. It was before North Korea had tested its first nuclear device. It was before the U.S. cut a deal with Iran to overlook its past nuclear transgressions in exchange for a temporary freeze on its nuclear program and a free pass to test missiles.
In 2017, though, Haley’s warnings and the cruder ones from her boss, President Donald Trump, are disconnected from reality. And here it’s important to remember why the president and his envoys are making threats in the first place. All of this is in the service of a discredited policy to not allow North Korea to obtain a nuclear weapon. The idea has been to threaten, coddle and tempt Kim Jong Un to start negotiations that would lead to him abandoning them.
Well, this is never going to happen. America and its allies have been trying this for about a quarter century, and the North Koreans burn us every time. Now North Korea needs only to perfect a nuclear warhead that can survive re-entry into the atmosphere to have a credible nuclear threat against the U.S. As Michael Auslin, a fellow in contemporary Asia at the Hoover Institution, told me this week: “That’s only a matter of time. It’s a technical issue at this point. They are going to get it.”
So it’s time for a new approach: Give up. America should never “accept” North Korea as a nuclear weapon state. But it can end the pointless cycles of pressure and negotiation. The North Koreans have used all that posturing to buy time to perfect their nukes and the Chinese have artfully used that dance to distract us from countering China’s own predations.
And yes, I know “give up” sounds dangerously un-American. Let’s put it another way: Focus on a battle we have not yet lost.

North Korea is already a nuclear power. The U.S. needs to deal with it

Instead of wasting the resources of an already depleted State Department on preparing for more talks with representatives of an Asian prison state, America’s diplomats and strategic planners can focus on improving its deterrence against North Korea. American diplomacy and military bandwidth can be devoted to countering China’s militarization of the South China Sea and its broader economic and political strategy to turn our Pacific and East Asian allies into vassals of Beijing. In the future, Trump and his diplomats won’t have to spend their meetings with Chinese counterparts pleading with them to get their client state to behave. That’s China’s problem now. America is developing even better technology to shoot North Korean missiles out of the sky before they land.
Then there’s credibility. It’s true that America would have taken a hit with a “give up” strategy a few years ago. But today North Korea is almost there. Despite Trump’s occasional tweeted threats, it’s hard to believe he will order a pre-emptive strike. Even if he did, it would probably not be all that effective. The fact that North Korea tested its missile this week on a mobile launcher makes it that much more difficult to take out these sites. This says nothing of the risk that the North would retaliate with conventional artillery shells by destroying the capital of South Korea, Seoul.
Besides, nuclear weapons are expensive. Countries already integrated into the global system face penalties and pressure that outlaws like North Korea really don’t.
“By acknowledging the reality of North Korea as a nuclear power, it doesn’t automatically mean Zimbabwe wants a nuclear weapon,” Auslin told me. “Those who want nuclear weapons are already trying get them.”
To give up on prevention is to focus on treatment. We need more creative options to deal with the North Korean menace. No longer will American diplomats have to worry about how Pyongyang’s tyrant will react to senior officials speaking the truth about his debased regime. Kim Jong Un wants nukes so his regime can survive. Nuclear negotiations meant assuring him that America has no interest in seeing his people live in dignity and freedom. America will not have this problem anymore.
Think of the opportunities. The president could elevate and call attention to brave North Korean dissidents. He could encourage them to begin planning for a transition to Korean democracy. Imagine a White House conference: “Planning for a Korea Without the Kim Regime.” Who knows? With a little luck maybe a constellation of dissidents could form a government in exile. Giving up on stopping a North Korean nuke means getting America on the right side of Korean history.
Finally, there is the benefit of stability. Kim will no longer have the ability to throw the region and the world into crisis every time he tests a nuclear device or a missile. America should still try to sabotage his program through cyber viruses and more conventional means. But in the short term, Kim will lose his ability to get the world to focus on his threats whenever he wishes.
It’s something the Trump administration should think about. And maybe the next time Kim decides to provoke, the U.S. response can be measured and boring. The Pentagon should trot out some deputy assistant under secretary to say the U.S. frowns upon the latest move, but that North Korea knows full well what will happen if it ever attacks America or her allies. Meanwhile, Trump could tweet something about his upcoming White House conference: “Imagining a World Without North Korea.” It sure beats empty threats in the service of dead-end talks.

Related Stories
Trump calls his own intel chiefs extremely passive and naiveTrump calls his own intel chiefs 'extremely passive and naive'
Susan Boyle makes emotional appearance on America’s Got TalentSusan Boyle makes emotional appearance on America’s Got Talent
US, China to Share, Publicly Release Data From Dark Side of the Moon - NASAUS, China to Share, Publicly Release Data From Dark Side of the Moon - NASA
Hitachi scraps £16bn nuclear power station in WalesHitachi scraps £16bn nuclear power station in Wales
Kusal Perera heroics lead Sri Lanka to remarkable Test win in South AfricaKusal Perera heroics lead Sri Lanka to remarkable Test win in South Africa
News Trends
Jussie Smollett Angered And Devastated By Claims He Played A Role In His Own AttackJussie Smollett 'Angered And Devastated' By Claims He Played A Role In His Own Attack
Labour MPs Ann Coffey, Chuka Umunna, Luciana Berger, Angela Smith, Chris Leslie, Gavin Shuker And Mike Gapes Quit Party To Form The Independent GroupLabour MPs Ann Coffey, Chuka Umunna, Luciana Berger, Angela Smith, Chris Leslie, Gavin Shuker And Mike Gapes Quit Party To Form 'The Independent Group'
Carmaker Honda plans to close Swindon factoryCarmaker Honda plans to close Swindon factory
Presidents Day shows how time can change legacies. Just look at Washington and LincolnPresidents Day shows how time can change legacies. Just look at Washington and Lincoln
How time spent in space creates unusual immune-system impactHow time spent in space creates unusual immune-system impact
Trump slams SNL for mocking his national emergencyTrump slams 'SNL' for mocking his national emergency
Team LeBron rallies to beat Team Giannis, 178-164Team LeBron rallies to beat Team Giannis, 178-164
Conor McGregor hypes up Kron Gracie’s UFC debut on Velasquez vs Ngannou cardConor McGregor hypes up Kron Gracie’s UFC debut on Velasquez vs Ngannou card
Newport West Labour MP Paul Flynn dies aged 84Newport West Labour MP Paul Flynn dies aged 84
Shawn Mendes Gives a New Meaning to the Word Smolder in His Calvin Klein AdShawn Mendes Gives a New Meaning to the Word Smolder in His Calvin Klein Ad
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Trump calls his own intel chiefs extremely passive and naiveTrump calls his own intel chiefs 'extremely passive and naive'
Susan Boyle makes emotional appearance on America’s Got TalentSusan Boyle makes emotional appearance on America’s Got Talent
US, China to Share, Publicly Release Data From Dark Side of the Moon - NASAUS, China to Share, Publicly Release Data From Dark Side of the Moon - NASA
Hitachi scraps £16bn nuclear power station in WalesHitachi scraps £16bn nuclear power station in Wales
Kusal Perera heroics lead Sri Lanka to remarkable Test win in South AfricaKusal Perera heroics lead Sri Lanka to remarkable Test win in South Africa
News Trends
Jussie Smollett Angered And Devastated By Claims He Played A Role In His Own AttackJussie Smollett 'Angered And Devastated' By Claims He Played A Role In His Own Attack
Labour MPs Ann Coffey, Chuka Umunna, Luciana Berger, Angela Smith, Chris Leslie, Gavin Shuker And Mike Gapes Quit Party To Form The Independent GroupLabour MPs Ann Coffey, Chuka Umunna, Luciana Berger, Angela Smith, Chris Leslie, Gavin Shuker And Mike Gapes Quit Party To Form 'The Independent Group'
Carmaker Honda plans to close Swindon factoryCarmaker Honda plans to close Swindon factory
Presidents Day shows how time can change legacies. Just look at Washington and LincolnPresidents Day shows how time can change legacies. Just look at Washington and Lincoln
How time spent in space creates unusual immune-system impactHow time spent in space creates unusual immune-system impact
Trump slams SNL for mocking his national emergencyTrump slams 'SNL' for mocking his national emergency
Team LeBron rallies to beat Team Giannis, 178-164Team LeBron rallies to beat Team Giannis, 178-164
Conor McGregor hypes up Kron Gracie’s UFC debut on Velasquez vs Ngannou cardConor McGregor hypes up Kron Gracie’s UFC debut on Velasquez vs Ngannou card
Newport West Labour MP Paul Flynn dies aged 84Newport West Labour MP Paul Flynn dies aged 84
Shawn Mendes Gives a New Meaning to the Word Smolder in His Calvin Klein AdShawn Mendes Gives a New Meaning to the Word Smolder in His Calvin Klein Ad
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
North Korea: WATCH moment thousands rejoice after Kim Jong-un's rocket launch
NBC Not Planning to Pay Out Matt Lauer's Salary
Elon Musk will send his Tesla Roadster to Mars on a giant rocket
Gunman opens fire at California hospital
Russia plan for MILITARY intervention in North Korea to stop a NUCLEAR apocalypse
Key players in the Michael Flynn investigation
Jimbo Fisher’s $75M move isn’t supposed to happen in college football
Trump, on Twitter, says Tillerson will remain as top U.S. diplomat
Russia Says U.S. Media Will Be Banned From Parliament
Apple And Stanford University Launch Heart Study On Apple Watch
Ex-Trump national security adviser Michael Flynn pleads guilty after lying to FBI
Christmas market TERROR: German police called to BOMB in Potsdam – near Berlin
The World Cup draw is complete: See the groups
Former Catalan leaders appear before supreme court in Madrid
Tearful Selena Gomez Honors Life-Saving BFF At Billboard Women In Music Ceremony
Apple Pay and App Store updated for World AIDS Day: How to donate when you make a payment
Meghan Markle and Harry FIRST PICTURES: Meghan attends royal engagement in Nottingham
Tesla just switched on the world's biggest lithium-ion battery in Australia
'Six minutes until oblivion' North Korea will not give Seoul time to stop NUCLEAR strike
Saudi Air Force destroys ballistic missile launched from Yemen
Jimmy Kimmel takes on Roy Moore: 'I accept the invitation'
Jim Nabors, TV's the lovably naive Gomer Pyle, dies at 87
'Lady Bird' Named Best Picture by New York Film Critics Circle
OPEC and allies extend oil production cuts by 9 months
Theresa May says she is not afraid to criticise Donald Trump
What’s Barack up to? Obama to jet into Paris for ‘secret’ talks with Emmanuel Macron
London mayor hits Trump over anti-Muslim videos
Matt Lauer Speaks Out After Firing From 'Today' Show Over Sexual Abuse
Jay-Z admits to cheating on Beyonce and says music was their 'therapy'
North Korea's new Hwasong-15 missile: What the photos show
Trump Attacks China For Having ‘No Impact On Little Rocket Man’
Jared Kushner questioned about Michael Flynn in Mueller's Russia probe, reports say
U.S. and China hold security talks amid tensions over latest North Korea missile test
Elon Musk calls for URGENT laws on robots as they will soon be RISK to public
Donald Trump attacks Theresa May over her criticism of his far-right retweets
Report Claims Matt Lauer Gave Sex Toy, Exposed Himself To Female Employees
Slobodan Praljak, Bosnian war criminal dies after swallowing poison in court
Bitcoin at $11,000: What the heck is going on?
Bali volcano REVERSE global warming: NASA say Mount Agung could plunge earth into ice age
North Korea News: KREMLIN behind North Korea’s missiles? ICBM is copy of SOVIET nuke
Anthony Harvey, Oscar-Nominated Director of 'The Lion in Winter,' Dies at 87
Theresa May makes secret visit to Iraq
ESPN Cutting 150 Employees
Amazon's Cyber Monday was its biggest sales day ever
Trump retweets anti-Muslim videos
Trump Speaks Out On North Korea Missile Launch
UK could pay £50bn Brexit divorce bill after bowing to EU pressure
Jesus Christ tomb shock: Test results on holy site add PROOF tomb IS that of Christ
Major Apple security flaw grants admin access on macOS High Sierra without password
BREAKING: Kim Jong-un declares North Korea now a 'FULL nuclear force' that can strike US
Build fast, fix later: speed hurts quality at Tesla, some workers say
Ellen DeGeneres Reacts to Prince Harry, Meghan Markle Engagement
British Actress Accuses Harvey Weinstein of Sex Trafficking in Lawsuit
Report: Trump continues to question Obama's birth certificate
What to expect from Ivanka Trump’s whirlwind two-day ‘royal visit’ to India
World War 3 fears: North Korea launches ballistic missile - South Korea FIRES rocket back
Germany CHAOS: Merkel humiliated as minister IGNORES her orders on EU vote
Airbnb now lets you split the cost of rentals
'Game of Thrones' gets its first Grammy nomination
‘I make Mommy moves’: Parody of Cardi B’s ‘Bodak Yellow’ captures reality of parenting
Angela Lansbury: attractive women 'must sometimes take the blame' for sexual harassment
Oscars: Canada's 'Hochelaga, Land of Souls' Chronicles Over 750 Years of Montreal History
Serena Williams' coach: No decision yet about Australian Open
Unique Adolf Hitler aquarelle painting of old Vienna uncovered
Miss Universe 2017 Winner Crowned in Las Vegas As Contestants Speak About Sexual Harassment
Trevor Noah Mockingly Praises Trump’s ‘Right Racism’ Of ‘Pocahontas’ Slur
Rex Tillerson’s State Department Reorganizer Resigns After Just 3 Months
China invest in 'BIG BROTHER' satellite to track US military in case WAR breaks out
SoftBank offers to buy Uber shares at 30 percent discount
Rocket Maker SpaceX Raises Another $100 Million
Barack Obama Congratulates Prince Harry And Meghan Markle On Engagement
Why Russia produces (and quashes) so much radical art
We should have a ‘FAKE NEWS TROPHY’: Trump attacks the media in his first post-Thanksgiving tweet
NASA launched this record into space in 1977. Now, you can own your own copy
AWS launches Amazon Sumerian to build AR, VR and 3D apps quickly
Bali volcano evacuation zones: Is Mount Agung dangerous? Threat to life warning issued
Sen. Al Franken apologizes for letting people down and vows to regain their trust
Meghan Markle and Prince Harry appear together for first time as engaged couple
Bitcoin Price LIVE: Cryptocurrency soars to record $9,600 - market fears bubble WILL burst
How to stop your Apple iPhone autocorrecting all your swear words
'Thrilled and very happy' Meghan Markle and Prince Harry to be married in spring 2018
Pope Francis Arrives in a Myanmar Tarnished by Rohingya Crackdown
Sony TV Books U.K. UFO Series From 'Doctor Who' Director
The Walking Dead: season eight, episode five recap – The King, the Widow and Rick
Bali volcano latest: 100,000 evacuated as Mount Agung lava eruption IMMINENT
Al Franken Is 'Embarrassed And Ashamed' By Sexual Misconduct Claims But Won't Resign
Vaccines and aid workers arrive in Yemen after blockade
Japan's latest driverless car hits the Tokyo highway
Suddenly fired Tesla workers speaking out about dismissals
Get an Amazon Alexa device for a fraction of the cost this Cyber Week
Actress Naya Rivera charged with domestic battery
IMGUR HACK: Find out if YOUR account was HACKED, how to change password, protect yourself
France to tackle violence on women; Italy grapples with same
Five killed as stolen car crashes into tree in Leeds
Everything You Need to Know About Cyber Monday
Selena Gomez Is 'Crazy In Love' With Justin After Reuniting: She's 'Light & Joyful'
Iran vows to ‘extend missile range if threatened by Europe’
Fox News Is ‘Much More Important’ Than CNN, Trump Tweets
China explosion: 2 killed in port city of Ningbo
The Model 3 is putting Tesla in dangerous territory
In retaliatory move, Putin signs media 'foreign agents' law
Lionel Messi re-signs with FC Barcelona through 2021
2 dead, 250+ injured in Pakistan as police try to clear massive protests
Victoria's Secret Fashion Show 2017: ALL the pictures and highlights of the Shanghai show
If you’re worried about being hacked online, it might be time to ditch Google Chrome
Germany's Merkel speaks out against new election
Wireless-in-Space: NASA testing device for returning spacecraft to Earth
China blocks off North Korea from REST of the WORLD amid World War 3 fears
Jeff Bezos Is Now Worth $100 Billion Thanks to Black Friday
Egypt hunts down killers after 235 killed in mosque attack
Ivanka Trump and Chelsea Clinton come to Malia Obama’s defence after tabloid scrutiny
BREAKING: Police release images of men who may have information about Oxford Street panic
Tillerson's senior team planning to skip Ivanka Trump's India trip
Trump tweets he 'took a pass' at being named TIME's person of the year
Oxford Circus terror: Video shows shoppers run away SCREAMING after 'shots fired'
Trump is hitting the links with Tiger Woods and Dustin Johnson
Oxford Circus terror: Shots heard on Oxford St police warn Black Friday shoppers STAY AWAY
World War 3: Putin responds to US threat with new anti-ballistic missile tests
PUTIN’S FEAR: Trump is using North Korea as guise to line up troops near RUSSIA
Nearly 200 reportedly killed in Egypt mosque attack
Michael Flynn’s lawyer ends co-operation with Trump’s legal team
Theresa May pushes for Brexit talks progress as she arrives in Brussels
Black Friday CHAOS: Amazon workers in Italy and Germany WALK OUT - ‘we want a bonus’
Melania Trump swaps THOSE stilettos for baseball cap to join Donald Trump in Florida
North Korea sacks soldiers, South Korea awards medals after defector's border dash
Russia Is Roaring Back to the Middle East While America Is Asleep
Navy ends its search for 3 missing sailors in the Philippine Sea
EU privacy regulators to discuss Uber hack next week
THANKSGIVING HORROR: Gunman opens fire at high school - at least three injured
17 years without a raise? Welcome to Brexit Britain
Iraqi woman unveils harrowing memoir about being a sex slave for Daesh
Huge ‘toxic’ cloud engulfs Brussels - Locals told to STAY INDOORS as 200 evacuated
Russia says Google down-ranking Sputnik, RT would be censorship
Trump touts his leadership during Thanksgiving teleconference with troops
Donald Trump to Americans: Go incorporate yourself
'Explosion' detected near site of missing Argentinian submarine, navy confirms
Germany must NOT be Europe's political dwarf: Merkel warned MACRON will rise up to lead EU
Tesla has built the world's biggest battery in Australia
NO JUSTICE: Outrage as Zimbabwe grants Robert Mugabe IMMUNITY and protection for resigning
Paris RIOTS: Students CLASH with riot police as they make stand against Macron reform
Search for Argentine submarine enters 'critical phase'
Christmas cancelled: Riot police and protestors clash - smoke bombs erupt on Paris streets
Hiding a hack? Uber promised not to do things like that
Netflix-Weinstein Co. Joint Golden Globes Party Discontinued
France calls UN Security Council meeting over Libya slave auctions
Macron urges Iran and Israel to 'work together' to ease Middle East tensions
Gabby Douglas: US Olympic star alleges abuse by Dr. Larry Nassar
Google tracks YOUR location on Android smartphones – even when you tell it not to
Ivanka Trump COPIES Melania in red outfit for Turkey ceremony in White House
Apple scientists disclose self-driving car research
Donald Trump calls LaVar Ball an 'ungrateful fool'
Eight found alive after U.S. Navy plane crash, three remain missing
Watch: Shock footage of North Korean defector escaping across border under hail of bullets
'This Is Us' Star Chrissy Metz Opens Up About Kate's Miscarriage
Lebanon's PM puts resignation on hold
Trump and Putin spoke about Syria, North Korea in phone call: White House
David Cassidy, teen heartthrob of 'The Partridge Family,' dies at 67
Uber data breach: personal data of 57 million hacked last year
The END of Angela Merkel: Chancellor’s fall from top 'to come quickly’ - Germany warned
Barron Trump back in the spotlight for White House holiday events
How a New Oscars Rule Could Shake Up the Animation Contenders
Terrifying video shows 26ft waves lash rescue boats searching for missing submarine crew
Apple removes several apps, including Skype, in China
Robert Mugabe resigns after 37 years as Zimbabwe's leader
Never say #NeverTrump
ALIEN asteroid Oumuamua captured entering Earth's solar system in stunning pictures
Oscars: 'Get Out' and 'Dunkirk' Fight to Get Voters' Attention After Early Release
Amazon Launches ‘Secret’ Cloud Service For Intelligence Agencies
BREAKING: Nigeria terror attack: At least 15 dead after suicide bomber strikes mosque
Chinese social media giant is worth more than Facebook
Putin to speak with Trump after meeting with Syrian President Assad
End of Robert Mugabe? Brutal regime to end as own party file impeachment motion TODAY
Trump asks Supreme Court for full enforcement of travel ban
‘The Voice’: Top 12 Perform Live for America’s Vote
'Battle of the Sexes': How Emma Stone Became Billie Jean King With a Tan and '70s Haircut
Trump declares North Korea a state sponsor of terrorism
Macron, Trump and Putin would all like to see Merkel go
Bitcoin price SOARS above $8,200 to hit new record high for crypto token
Megyn Kelly Takes Aim at Hollywood Hypocrisy Over Sexual Harassment Scandal
Missing sub: Argentina navy detects noises
Jana Novotna, former Wimbledon tennis champion, dies aged 49
Selena Gomez debuts blond hair at American Music Awards for first performance of 2017
Paul Pogba dedicates goal to migrants sold as slaves in Libya
Brexit victory? EU finally admit bloated budget WILL collapse without huge UK contribution
Charles Manson dies aged 83 after four decades in prison
Merkel's 4th term in doubt as German coalition talks fail
Kim Jong-un 'gravely' ill? Lack of North Korea missile tests spark rumours about dictator
American Music Awards: Taylor Swift Sends Heartfelt Message to Honoree Diana Ross
Arab League states condemn Hezbollah as 'terrorist organization'
Donald Trump fires back at LaVar Ball: 'I should have left them in jail!'
No one can prevent Trump from using nuclear weapons, experts say
Camerimage: 'On Body and Soul' Wins Golden Frog
Zimbabwe’s ruling party fires Robert Mugabe as leader
Most Canadians Rate Justin Trudeau's Economic Performance Rated As Poor, Very Poor, Or Average: Poll
Violence on the streets of Paris as protesters rage against Macron for fifth day
A brand-new version of WhatsApp is in the works, here’s everything we know so far
Hillary Clinton: Trump 'is obsessed' with me
Proof of time travel? 'Futuristic' man ‘from 2028’ issues chilling warning in video clip
Signals may be from missing sub, Argentina's navy says
U.S. general says nuclear launch order from Trump can be refused
Close