October 07, 2020
You’re reading The Waugh Zone, our daily politics briefing. Sign up now to get it by email in the evening.
Is Keir Starmer Ready To End His ‘Constructive Opposition’?
Labour really stuck it to the government today. The country has a soaring R rate thanks to “a complete failure to tackle the spread of the virus”. Ministers took too long to set up test-and-trace. More cash should go to businesses “now at risk because of its incompetence”. While public health is the priority, people’s jobs must now be protected.
But guess what? The government under fire was Nicola Sturgeon’s, and the country in question was Scotland. Yes, it was Labour’s shadow Scottish secretary (and only MP north of the border) Ian Murray who was scathing today about the first minister’s handling of the pandemic.
Sturgeon certainly made a huge call in going ahead with her 16-day crackdown on hospitality in Scotland, itself the kind of “circuit break” that Boris Johnson has been pondering but so far has refused to commit to. And the criticism she faced just underscored that for any party in government, this is a really tough time politically.
Sturgeon’s huge advantage is that – unlike Johnson in England – her party is way ahead of Labour in the polls and her personal popularity is still very high. However, although both leaders have long taken comfort from the fact that most of the public back tough restrictions no matter where they live in the UK, patience with their performance may be starting to fray among both business leaders and battle-weary residents suffering local lockdowns.
But while Labour has long been critical of the Scottish government, Keir Starmer has stuck to his “constructive opposition” approach with their Tory counterparts in London. Until today, that is. The gloves really came off in Prime Minister’s Questions as Starmer hounded the PM over the 10pm curfew, test and trace and lack of help for local lockdown areas.
Johnson performed better this week, yet still had few answers to the direct questions on why he had not published scientific evidence for the curfew, why test and trace was still failing or why some areas were in lockdown when other (Tory MP areas) weren’t despite similar Covid levels. As ever the best PMQs are the unanswerable ones, and asking why the virus was still soaring in Bury, Burnley and Bolton (all seats taken by the Tories from Labour, note) despite lockdown exposed that perhaps Johnson is as baffled as anyone else.
As roadtested in his interview with me last week, Starmer also managed to turn the “Captain Hindsight” jibe back on Johnson. “The prime minister ignores the warning signs, hurtles towards a car crash, then looks in the rear mirror and says, ‘What’s all that about?’ It is quite literally government in hindsight.”
Now it’s true that for a long time Johnson’s effective response to criticism has been to say: well, what’s your alternative then? For months, Starmer has insisted he is not trying to “second guess” ministers, and has no alternative plan. Today, his spokesman said Labour did have a credible alternative, saying it would fix test and trace, was the first to call for 24 hour testing, to call for German-style clarity on criteria for lockdown/unlockdown and so on.
It may be that Gogglebox Labour voters have sparked this more confrontational approach. But it’s more likely that Starmer is once again doing what he did on Brexit, iterating his stance as he goes along while keeping that strategically patient eye on his big strength: an image of competence compared to repeated government failures that directly affect millions.
Starmer does know that this is a very tricky balancing act and that the public dislike carping. Given he wants to rebuild bridges with business and need to save jobs, he can’t call for tougher lockdowns without strong cause. Yet the sight of him at least trying to provide alternatives could pay off politically.
Next week’s vote on the 10pm curfew is already causing ministers a real headache precisely because Labour could for the first time oppose the government. But if he does go down that route, Starmer will have to make crystal clear what his alternative is to curfew. A 11pm closing time with matching shop alcohol sales (as in Northern Ireland as some ministers want)? A Scottish style firebreak closure of some pubs completely? 
Crucially, Starmer knows that Johnson is going to have to impose yet further tough curbs in some areas and that the PM is constantly in fear of being seen to blame the public for any sharp rise in hospitalisations and deaths. It’s not inconceivable he could just make the government squirm, then back it or abstain next week, while waiting for Johnson to make himself more unpopular with tougher curbs.
Most important of all, having overpromised things would be back to normal by Christmas, Johnson is now open to the Starmer charge that he really was asleep at the wheel when he should have been preparing this summer for a winter of discontent.
The PM said in July he was hoping for the best while planning for the worst. He still has a fair amount of goodwill, but If the public think he did the former and not the latter, he and his party really will be in trouble. And not just in Bury, Blackburn and Bolton.Related... Starmer Brushes Off Unite Union £150,000 Funding Cut To Labour Keir Starmer Demands Boris Johnson Justify 10pm Pub Curfew Ahead Of Crunch Vote Has Keir Starmer’s ‘Strong On Security’ Stance Found Its Limits On The Covert Sources Bill?
Related Stories
Latest News
Top news around the world
Coronavirus Disease

Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) is an infectious disease caused by a newly discovered coronavirus.

Most people infected with the COVID-19 virus will experience mild to moderate respiratory illness and recover without requiring special treatment. Older people, and those with underlying medical problems like cardiovascular disease, diabetes, chronic respiratory disease, and cancer are more likely to develop serious illness.

Around the World

Celebrity News

> Latest News in Media

Watch It
Food Before Sex?, Wedding From Hell & Sleeping With an Ex
March 02, 2021
44jdnqHQQRc
Golden Pop Awards: Best Jokes, Boldest Fashion & Celeb Homes
March 02, 2021
5KS7QwCexUU
Kim Kardashian's Hairdresser Trolls Her For Falling Asleep | E! News
March 01, 2021
R8heLa1FkQ8
Why Jodie Foster Thanked Aaron Rodgers At The Golden Globes
March 01, 2021
FtNteU6Xbbk
Best Moments from the 2021 Golden Globes
March 01, 2021
e-iUYh4kFYI
'Nomadland' Director Chloe Zhao On Her Historic Golden Globe Win
March 01, 2021
AMjFTiRh8wA
Inside Tiger Woods’ ex Elin Nordegren’s new $10M Palm Beach mansion | Page Six Celebrity News
March 01, 2021
7sDs4aCAtIk
Canelo Alvarez kicks two Jake Paul fans out of ring | Page Six Celebrity News
March 01, 2021
qt0ztAYkOcg
Hilaria and Alec Baldwin welcome baby No. 6 — five months after baby No. 5 | Page Six Celebrity News
March 01, 2021
c3hvS_zqMzw
Dr. Oz Saves Man's Life at Newark Airport After He Collapsed | TMZ
March 02, 2021
oTlcddzgqs0
Questlove Says Calling Out HFPA's Lack of Diversity is Lip Service, Until it Changes | TMZ
March 02, 2021
wASYH939qRc
Surveillance Video Shows Men Open Fire on Laney Keyz's L.A. Home | TMZ
March 02, 2021
_T4zh30UhkY
TV Schedule
Late Night Show
Watch the latest shows of U.S. top comedians

Sports

Latest sport results, news, videos, interviews and comments
Find us on Instagram
at @feedimo to stay up to date with the latest.
Featured Video You Might Like
zWJ3MxW_HWA L1eLanNeZKg i1XRgbyUtOo -g9Qziqbif8 0vmRhiLHE2U JFCZUoa6MYE UfN5PCF5EUo 2PV55f3-UAg W3y9zuI_F64 -7qCxIccihU pQ9gcOoH9R8 g5MRDEXRk4k
Copyright © 2020 Feedimo. All Rights Reserved.